Regardless, Trump’s abrupt announcement on Tuesday that new tariffs on Chinese goods would be delayed inadvertently provided some clarity on the US economy.
President Trump’s decisions on the US-China trade war reflect a method to the madness, his supporters insist. To everyone else, it just appears to be madness. Regardless, Trump’s abrupt announcement on Tuesday that new tariffs on Chinese goods would be delayed inadvertently provided some clarity on the US economy.
Soon after the news was released, US stocks surged. The implication: a fair amount of the recent weakness in US economic growth is bound up with the US-China trade war. Absent this self-inflicted policy, output would be stronger and recession fears would fade.
Yes, that’s speculation, and it’s based on one day of implied analysis via a pop in the stock market. Caveat emptor. Nonetheless, it’s striking that equities bounced following a decision to delay new tariffs. The implication: a key headwind for the US macro trend could, in theory, vanish tomorrow if the US and China resolve their trade differences, or at least tone down the worst impulses.
Tantalizing as that is, it’s premature to read too much into yesterday’s market reaction—or Trump’s announcement. The president has a history of erratic decisions on trade and other topics and so today’s manna from heaven could quickly fade in a new tweetstorm from Trump.
It doesn’t help that Trump’s reversal on tariffs appears driven by political calculations rather than a shift in policy. “The three-month delay to the imposition of tariffs on more than half of the $300 billion of Chinese imports, originally scheduled to take effect next month, is obviously designed to avoid a politically-damaging rise in consumer prices ahead of the holiday season,” says Andrew Hunter, senior US economist, at Capital Economics. He continues:
It should not be misinterpreted as a sign that trade tensions are easing. Tensions will probably continue to ebb and flow over the coming months, resulting in further bouts of volatility(NYSEARCA:VXX) in the markets, but we still see a continued escalation as the most likely outcome.
The CEO of the US Chamber of Commerce claims that putting new tariffs on ice is a merely a calculation that doing so would lower recession risk, which had been rising recently, based on some metrics—the inverted Treasury yield curve, for example. “Nobody wants to run for president, on either party, in the middle of a recession,” says Tom Donohue.
Whatever the catalyst, the White House is sensitive to expectations for the economy and the financial markets. The recent slide in Treasury yields, signaling rising concern that recession risk is rising, is probably a factor in Trump’s latest pivot. In turn, it’s reasonable to expect that if economic expectations sink further, the White House will pull back on its trade-war tactics.
Goldman Sachs Group Inc. chief economist Jan Hatzius wrote in a note to clientsthat the delay of tariffs “is an incrementally positive sign” because “it suggests that the disruption in financial markets over the last several days could have led to a softening of the White House position.”
In any case, the events of the past 24 hours strongly suggest that the US economy’s outlook remains solid—if trade-war risk evaporates or is substantially reduced. Reality, alas, is more complicated and so the crowd is forced to factor in Trump’s mercurial decision-making process for estimating the economic path ahead.
The good news is that forward momentum for the US economy remains positive, based on a broad set of indicators, notwithstanding the bond market’s dire outlook. The trade war is still a factor, and will likely remain so for the near term. Exactly how much blowback the economy will endure on this front is unclear, largely because the White House seems to be making up policy on the fly, with little or no strategic goal.
The larger point is that a US recession, at this point, isn’t fate. There’s still time to secure and extend what is now the longest period of growth on record. It’s an expansion, Mr. Trump, if you can keep it.