Is A Flattening of Yield Curve Signaling a Weakening US Economy?
Cleveland Federal Reserve President Loretta Mester on Monday said that the recent flattening of the yield curve isn’t a sign that the US economy is weakening.
Her comment follows a similar observation by Fed Chairman Jerome Powell, who suggested last week that low inflation in recent years has reduced the value of monitoring recession risk based on differences between long and short Treasury yields.
Mester advised that there is “no evidence” for thinking that a flatter curve signals a weaker economy at this time, Reuters reported. She added that “structural factors,” such as bond-buying by central banks, are compressing the curve.
Mester’s comments coincided with a further narrowing of the yield spread based on the 10-year (NYSEARCA:IEF)and 2-year Treasury rates. The yield difference between the two maturities fell to 52 basis points yesterday (Mar. 27), close to the lowest level since the recession ended in mid-2009. In January, the 10-year/2-year spread dipped to 50 basis points, a post-recession low.
Sign up for our Newsletter & get the FREE eBook
Retirement Day Trader:
How to Sell Weekly Options for Steady Income
This isn’t the first time that the Cleveland Fed President has raised doubts about the yield curve’s value for business-cycle analysis. Late last year, Bloomberg reported that she dismissed concerns that a flattening yield curve was a warning sign for the economy. “I just think long rates are going to go up given where we are in the economy and given where we see the economy going,” she said. “But this is another reason why we need to keep raising up the short rate.”
Fast forward nearly four months and current pricing in Fed funds futures supports Mester’s analysis. Following last week’s rate hike, CME this morning reports that Fed funds futures are pricing in a 96% probability that the central bank will raise rates again at the May 2 policy meeting.
Meanwhile, recession risk remains virtually nil, based on data published to date, according to yesterday’s February update of the Chicago Fed National Activity Index. The business cycle benchmark’s three-month moving average increased to +0.37, far above the -0.70 level that marks the start of economic contractions.
Last week’s US business-cycle risk profile also reflected low recession risk.
Is it time to dump the Treasury yield curve as an early warning of economic trouble? No, although the apparent mismatch between current conditions and the flattening curve serves as a reminder that no one business indicator is flawless.
True, but there’s an alternative interpretation: the narrowing rate spread sees weakneses down the road. Indeed, the literature on yield-curve analysis indicates that warnings in this corner are predictions rather than nowcasts. By that reasoning, the jury’s still out on the final verdict for yield curve analytics in the post-Great Recession era.